The Chipped Plate and the Comparison Trap: Why Progress Is Not A Straight Line

©The MBT Blog – Mindfulness in Business Coaching | Journaling & Growth | MBT More Mindful Business Today

A few years ago, when I was purging old items from my house, I found our wedding china in a box in the basement. What started as a simple decluttering project turned into a full lesson for myself about comparison, imperfection, and why both of those things are far more connected than I ever realized.

Let me back up.

Here is the thing: when I packed that special dinnerware years ago, all I could see were the flaws. One dinner plate has a noticeable chip on the edge. We never completed a full set before the pattern was discontinued, so we are stuck with four place settings, a platter, and zero bowls. I remember feeling almost embarrassed by it back then. A chipped plate, an incomplete set — not exactly the picture-perfect china I thought I should have.

But when I opened that box again ten years later, something completely different happened. I was no longer embarrassed by it. I felt happiness mixed with sentimentality. I remembered picking out that bold, art deco black pattern with my soon-to-be husband, feeling daring and grown-up. I looked at that china on the day I “refound” it and thought, “I love this. I would be proud to use it the next time friends come over.”

My perspective changed so completely over the years. It started me pondering what really changed. I no longer compared my tableware to that of others. My special porcelain no longer was the symbol of my success or lack of success. Now, the longevity of my marriage and the decades of memories warm my heart and fill me up. We met nearly 30 years ago and said “I do” more than 28 years ago. I am not concerned about what others may think about my china.

The Comparison Trap Hiding Underneath It All

In my work with clients as the Mindful Business Coach, one of the first things I ask people is to describe their aspirations. Not what is on their to-do list this week, but the larger question of what they actually want their work and life to look like, their vision for themselves. Almost every time, clients describe those aspirations using other people as reference points. “I want to build a business like hers.” “I want to have the kind of confidence he has.” I love this part of the process. Clients piece together their own version of success using bits and pieces of the lives of people they admire. The lives they can see, that is.

Used this way, comparison is healthy. It is clarifying, even.

But comparison has a shadow side as well. It appears when a client begins to feel unworthy because their progress does not match someone else’s. That is when things become heavy. Clients freeze. They express a sense of hopelessness. The language shifts into extremes: “I will never get there.” “I always do something wrong.”

When always and never reveal themselves, it is time to take a break.

I know this because I have lived it. In the days when I packed that china, I was deep in my own always-and-never space. Then, all those years later, I realized my work to dispel the negativity of comparison had born fruit. I had moved myself into a new, confident place. In this new perspective, I appreciated the happy side of the life I built with my husband.

I just had to share this in today’s blog post. Comparing ourselves to others can be good in moderation, because it shows us what is possible. Imperfection reminds us that we are allowed to be a work in progress while we get there. Both are necessary if we want to keep moving forward without losing ourselves in the process.

So How Did I “work on” the always-never of comparison?

Here is what I did for myself and how I help my clients. I do not believe the goal is to eliminate comparison or erase our flaws entirely. The goal is to bring a little more intention to both.

On comparison:

• Notice how it makes you feel. If you feel motivated, that is likely a good thing. If you feel unworthy or stuck, take a break. What makes you feel that way?
• Write down how you feel. Putting the feeling on paper takes away some of its power. It is also a great way to see trends in yourself and raise your awareness. If you are interested in doing more of that, consider signing up for one of our Group Journaling classes.
• If you feel bad, concentrate on the positive. What went well for you this past week or month? Take a moment to acknowledge the good things you did.
• Take out your plan. If you have a plan for your professional and business development, take a look at it. How can you jump back into action? Do your accomplishments match your goals?
• If your accomplishments do match your goals, pause to celebrate. Do not simply nod and move on.
• If they do not, think about the next action to take. Not the entire path forward, only the next step.
• Remember, each action you take brings you closer to your goal. Progress does not need to look dramatic to count.

The Real Takeaway

The china did not need to be a complete set for me to love it again. And I do not need to be free of flaws to keep growing. Comparison, used well, points us toward who we want to become. Imperfection, accepted honestly, keeps us grounded while we get there. Neither one is the enemy. It is losing the balance between them that causes trouble.

How about you? How do you balance yourself? If you want to discuss it, give coaching a try. Set up an appointment for a consultation.